TidBITS#712/12-Jan-04 offers detailed analysis of the MacWorld announcements from last week. While Adam’s lead editorial struck me as less sharp than he’s capable of (it felt more like justification than analysis, something that may be borne out by his noting that he’s not a music-oriented Mac user), the detailed discussion of iLife 04, in particular, is worthwhile.

Non-Mac iPod users: what do you think of Adam’s thesis?